| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Rapidkreuzer |
Naval changes | #1 | ||
|
Can the french really afford to transfer so many ships to the Channel? Right now there are just the 5 Dantons, 4 Courbets and 2 Bretagne class ships who are a
real threat to the KuK-Navy. The British forces consist mainly of PreDNs, so I wonder if it will encourage Haus for another sortie or the Turks to send Goeben
and Breslau.
|
||||
|
|
||||
miketr |
KuK Navy... | #2 | ||
|
The Hapsburgs have 3 DN's and 3 PDN's with a collection of coast defense ships to back them up but only 4 modern cruisers and a few DD's/TB's.
Right now the French can keep them bottled up fairly effectively. France also has a good collection of PDN's themselves; 10 in total as a I recall and
those are only the most modern ones with mixed 12" and 9.4" batteries. They have a number of older ships.
The real question is what can France hope to do if they do move their ships north? The HSF is shot up but they would need to send a strong enough force to achieve something. Which would be their entire force of DN's (6 ships) and Semi-DN's (10 ships) and even then would it be enough to defeat the German fleet if they run into without GF support? That would leave the scrap metal brigade to cover the Med which would provide a strong temptation for the Italians let alone the Hapsburgs to do something. My own thought is the Germans would cut the French fleet to bits because of the French lack elevation on their guns. Worst choice would be to send only a partial force and have that run into the Germans and whiped out while at the same time giving the Hapsburgs something like parity. At the same time the French face economic starvation with shipments from the UK. It is a damned if you do and damned if you don't choice. The more prudent choice would be to offer the British a squadron of French ships under French command but as part of the GF. That or nothing or start ordering supplies form the US and convoy them with some PDN's. Michael
Just my $0.02 worth
|
||||
|
|
||||
CJvR |
#3 | |||
|
real question is what can France hope to do if they do move their ships north?
It would depend on the lighter forces available rather than the battleline. If they want to do something alone they are rather restricted in their options. The French could move subs and TBs to the channel to help prevent the HSF from using it like an Irish-German Autobahn with a few PDN at Brest in support. If the objective is to keep the Atlantic ports open then the basic strategy would be a BS stationed at Brest with sub and cruiser patrols in the bay of Biscay. Such an arrangement would make it troublesome for the HSF raiders to operate south of Brest without heavy units in support and that is an unlikely use of the HSF. Although that will not solve the main problem which is the traffic on the English ports. If you mean to open up the English channel again on a more permanent basis then the best move would be to attach a DN squadron with supporting units to the GF and hope for the best in the inevitable clash. The French are not capable of taking on the HSF alone.
Last Edited By: CJvR 07/01/09 10:36:57.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
TomB1 |
MN 1ere Armee Navale | #4 | ||
|
And 3 of the Courbet and Voltaire are still in the yards from Battle of Cattaro Gulf. The Bretagne class are not yet complete (Provence is almost done though) |
||||
|
|
||||